The following entiries were obtained from the Hotten book 8a from the Musters of the Inhabitants in Virginia 1624/1625 chapters, pages 201 thru 265, which lists the muster captain, and what ship the individual arrived on.  

Coldham reports the Merchant of London was sent by the Virginia Company in March 1620 with 200 persons, pg 22

Attkins, Richard, aged 24 at muster, Mulberie Island, servant to Capt William Pierce. Wife, Abigall on the Abigail.
Ball, Robart, 1619 voyage, aged 27 at muster Eastern Shore.
Barnabie, John, 1620 voyage, aged 21 at muster, Elizabeth City.
Blore, Francis, 1620 voyage, aged 25 at muster at Eastern Shore, wife of John onStar.
Bourbicth, Edward at muster at James City.
Branch, Christopher, his wife, Mary and Thomas, 9 mos at muster
Bridgewater, Richard, with wife Isabell.
Coltman, Ann, 1619 voyage, aged 26 at muster, wife of Henry on the 1610 Noah
Cooke, Ellin, 1620 voyage, aged 25 at muster, servant to Robert Partin on the 1609 Blessing
Crew, Joseph
Cugley, Danniell, 1620 voyage, aged 28 at muster Eastern Shore, with William Andros.
Culley, Samuell, muster at Martin's Hundred.
Day, John and wife 1620 voyage, Hog Island as one of Sir George Yearley's men.
Fernall, Robert, 1619 voyage, aged 31 at muster at Mathews Plant, James City as servant to Capt Samuel Mathews. 
Frier, Ursula, wife to George on William & Thomas.
Hall, Susan, wife of John on the John & Francis.
Jones, Thomas and wife Margaret.
Jorden, Peeter, on 1620 ship, aged 22 at muster
Lipps, John, 1621 voyage.
Milnhouse, John, aged 36 at muster as a Governor's Man at Pasbehaighs, James City.
Moyses, Theoder
Peeters, Mary, 1620 voyage, aged 16 at muster. Servant to Richard Biggs on the Swan.
Pinke, Henery,  1619 voyage, muster at Wariscoyack as servant to Edward Bennett.
Potter, Ann, at muster at Elizabeth City, under John Ward, wife to Henrie, unk ship?
Richards, Richard, 1620 voyage, muster at Burrow's Hill, James City.
Smith, Richard
Sully, Maudlyn, 1620 voyage, aged 30 at muster, Elizabeth City with Thomas on 1611 Sara.
Taylor, Dorothy, 1620 voyage, aged 21 at muster. 
Thompson, Roger, 1620 voyage, aged 40 at muster, servant to Sir George Yearley at James City, 1624. Listed with wife Ann.
Turner, Henery
Wethersbie, Dorothie, 1620 voyage, aged 30 at muster Elizabeth City, wife to Bart on the Providence.

Pilgrim Ship Lists
Pilgrim Ship Passengers
Genealogy Main Page