Please note the conflicting dates of 1620 and 1621. If the ship left Sept 1620, it would have had to have landed Jan 1621,
yet so many documents have the ship listed as arriving in the colonies in January of 1620.

The Supply was the companion ship to the Mayflower. It left three weeks late from Bristol, England and found it's way to Barclay, Virginia on January 29, 1620/1

RECORDS OF THE VIRGINIA COMPANY

CLIV. SIR George Yeardley. Certificate to the Council and Company of Virginia of the arrival of Planters at Barklay January 29, 1620/21

Smyth of Nibley Papers, Smith 34

Document in New York Public Library. Autograph signed of "George Yeardley" and "Jo: Pory, Secr.," Seal and Stamp (Double Rose). List of Records No.228

[SEAL] These are to certifie the right Honble Right worshipfull, and others of the Counsell and Comany for this first Southern Colony of Virginia, that there arrived at Barklay in the same country, for the account of that Society, and the Plantation fothe said hundred, upon the 29th of January 1620, these fifty persons underwritten. Vist.

Baily, John, died by 03 Sep 1620 
Baker, Robert, died by 03 Sept 1620  
Baugh, Thomas (at Virginia for 1624/25 muster 8a) alive 03 Sep 1620 
Broadway, Giles, slain by 03 Sep 1620, Alexander listed alive 
Camme, Nicolas gent, Came, returned to Englnad in "same ship" 1621
Carter, Giles, died in England
Coopy, Joane, died by 03 Sept 1620 
Coopy, Antony, son of Joane, alive 03 Sept 1620 
Coopy, Elizabeth, daughter of Thomas & Joane, alive  03 Sept 1620
Diuine, Robert Pawlett Divine?
Dutton, Richard, died by 03 Sept 1620 
Ferriby, Richard gent, slain by 03 Sep 1620 
Finche, Margaret his wife (at Virginia for 1624/25 muster with husband John Fludd on 1610 Swan 8a)
Finche, Francis, her daughter, married by 01 Aug 1622(at Virginia for 1624/25 muster 8a)
Finche, William, son & wife Elizabeth, died by 03 Sept 1620, wife remarried, dtr Francis (listed as son William Fludd at Virginia for 1624/25 8a) same one? not likely.
Gibbes, John, servant to Oldsworth (at Virginia for 1624/25 muster, partner to Christopher Safford. 8a) 
Gifford, Isabell, married Adam Reymer at sea and departed to Joyce Tracy
Grevell, Francis, married Mr de la Warr by Sep 3 1620
Hall, George, Hale/Heale? Drummer (at Virginia for 1624/25 muster, aged 13 8a)
Heskins, Alice 
Holden, John gent, Holmeden? died by 03 Sep 1620 
Holland, Gabriel, died by 03 Sep 1620 
Holland, Richard
Howlett, John the elder, slain by 03 Sept 1620 
Howlett, John his sonne, died by 03 Sept 1620 
Howlett, William also his sonne, alive at 03 Sept 1620 
Jelfe, James, died by 03 Sept 1620  
Keene, George gent, returned to England
Kemys, Thomas governor, gent, Kemis
Linzey, Roger, Lindsey, stayed in Ireland
Long, Robert gent, Longe, died by 03 Sep 1620 
Milton, Richard (at Virginia for 1624/25 muster 8a) 
Oldsworth, Arnold  Esqr. died by 03 Sep 1620 
Page, John and wife Francis "went not but stayed in Ireland"
Prosser, Walter, died by 03 Sept 1620 
Rolles, Richard 
Rolles, Jane his wife
Rolles, Benedict their sonne
Sheepy, Thomas gent, Shepy (1624/5 VA muster, aged 22 8a)
Tracy William Esqr., died Apr 8, 1621
Tracy Mary his wife
Tracy Thomas their sonne, returned to England
Tracy Joice their daughter, married Capt Nathaniell Powell, both slain by 03 Sep 1620 
Vrange, Philip  
Webbe, Elizabeth, married by 03 Sep 1620 
Wilkins, Giles 

Compiled by Jim Gallman (jgallma1@tuelectric.com)

Notes by John Smyth's 03 Sep 1620 list per Coldham pg 20-21

Hotten ( 8a)  lists on the 1620 voyage:
Bradway, Alexander aged 31 at muster, wife Sisley was on the 1620 Jonathan
Collins, John, aged 30 at muster, wife Susan was on the 1613 Treasurer.
West, Mrs. Francis (widow)appears in Capt Francis West's muster at Elizabeth City beyond the Hampton River, 1624 with the Captain and Nathaniel born in VA.
From http://www.immigrantships.net/v3/1600v3/supply16200129.html:
The ship contained 56 passengers, Tobias Felgate was master, the ship's leak was repaired in Ireland where 6 passengers embarked and remained.

Roll order:
1  William Tracy          Esq
 2  Mary Tracy             his wife
 3  Thomas Tracy           their sonne
 4  Ioice Tracy            their daughter
 5  Francis Grevell
 6  Elizabeth Webbe
 7  Alice Heskins
 8  Isabell Gifford
 9  Giles Carter
10  George Hall
11  John Baily
12  Thomas Baugh
13  Gabriel Holland
14  Richard Holland
15  Giles Wilkins
16  Giles Broadway
17  Richard Dutton
18  Richard Milton
19  Ione Coopy
20  Antony Coopy
21  Elizabeth Coopy
22* Philip Wright Vrange  
23  John Page
24  Francys                his wife 
25  John Linzey
26  Roger Linzey
27  Arnold Olsworthy       Esq
28  Robert Pawlett Diuine 
29  Thomas Kemys           gent
30  Robert Long            gent
31  Iohn Holmden           gent
32  Richard Ferriby        gent
33  Thomas Sheepy          gent
34  George Keene           gent
35  Nicholas Camme         gent
36  William Finche
37  Margaret               his wife
38  Francis                their daughter
39  Iohn Gibbes            
40  Robert Baker
41  Iohn Howlett           the elder
42  Iohn Howlet            his sonnes
43  Willia' Howlet         his sonnes
44  Walter Prosser
45  James Ielfe
46  Richard Rolles
47  Jane                   his wife
48  Benedict Rolles        their soone
49  Alexander Broadway
50  Arthur Kemis           gent

Please note the conflicting dates of 1620 and 1621. If the ship left Sept 1620, it would have had to have landed Jan 1621, 
yet so many documents have the ship listed as arriving in the colonies in January of 1620. Supply sources: Coldham's Emigrants ftp://ftp.rootsweb.com/pub/usgenweb/va/shiplists/supply.txt http://www.immigrantships.net/v3/1600v3/supply16200129.html

Pilgrim Ship Lists
Pilgrim Ship Passengers
Genealogy Main Page